What Makes a Plant-Based Recipe “Good”?


What makes a good recipe? Here’s what I look for when I scan the page:

  1. Reasonable number of ingredients. Reading a long list of stuff I need to buy/prep makes me exhausted before I even get started, so less is definitely better.
  2. Accessibility of ingredients. Can I find the items at my local grocery on a regular basis or are they seasonal or hard-to-find?
  3. Ease of preparation. Are there so many complicated recipe components that one dish takes two hours to cook? Unless it’s Christmas or I have committed my day to bread-baking or ravioli-making, that’s a deal-breaker for me.
  4. Recognition. Yes, familiarity. I have found for my clients, and for my family, we like to return to dishes and flavors again and again that are familiar to our experience. What says comfort to you?
  5. Cost. Some ingredients are just ridiculously expensive. Here is where you have to use your instinctual higher judgement. Some cookbook authors assume that money is no object on the quest for the perfect plant-based meal.

Here are a couple highlights from this week’s library haul:


The Book of Veganish by Kathy Freston (2016)

This cookbook offers simple, economical no-nonsense recipes and lots of great everyday advice on making the transition to a vegan, plant-based lifestyle. I especially appreciate the relaxed language and easy-to-read page layouts with colorful images and text boxes throughout. A great starter book.


Natural Feasts by Ella Mills (2017)

First, a disclaimer. When you open it up you know you are stepping into a world. It’s easy to lose your way amidst the lush, natural light, the soft-focus images of radiantly healthy women and men beaming lovingly at one another over rustically styled food and furnishings and hand-picked botanicals. You get the sense that everyone loves Ella. And by the end, you realize you want to be Ella.

But behind all the window-dressing, Ella puts out quality recipes. I enjoyed her previous and more basic “Simply Ella” cookbook because she really focuses on creative combinations of whole foods in her recipes. Most of her dishes are low in sugar and oil and include simple, easy to find and afford ingredients, like butterbeans. Yes, butterbeans!

I highly recommend exploring your local library’s inventory of cookbooks to discover the right one(s) for you. Key words really matter when researching the database. Try vegan, plant-based, whole food, vegetarian, healthy, meatless, for example. And don’t give up entirely on conventional cookbooks and magazines for recipe inspiration. There are many recipes that are incidentally plant-based (like salad dressings, barbecue and other condiments).


The book business being what it is, publishers are looking to appeal to the widest audience, so don’t get hung up on labels. I have found many excellent vegan recipes hiding between the pages of lacto-ovo vegetarian cookbooks.

I have read that folks are cooking less nowadays, opting instead for grab n’ go meals, food delivery services, personal chefs (yay), restaurant dining and takeout  more often than not.

Nevertheless, for those of us who read them (and need them) as well as those of us who just like the pretty pictures, the plant-based cookbooks keep flying off the presses. And thank goodness for that!


  1. Melanie, my new favorite bread recipe was inspired by a recipe on a quilt. Someone texted me a photo of the recipe that was on a qullt at a local quilt show. My take on the recipe is now in my head and is considered quite the dinnertime treat: Artichoke Bread. I use my favorite quick pizza dough recipe, let it rise a few minutes,flatten it into a large rectangel, then add chopped artichoke hearts, fresh garlic, and a few other vegan things, and roll it up and bake.

  2. You are absolutely right with your opinion about the recipes.
    I often see mouthwatering dishes and when I start reading the ingredients, I already become desperate because many are either not available at all where I live, or crazy expensive. The same often applies to the preparation, too. 😞

    Thanks a lot for sharing your book recommendations 🙏
    Unfortunately, I don’t have a library available, but maybe I could buy one or two of the books. 😉👍

      1. Yes, indeed, they both often have reasonable priced books and ship almost everywhere in the world. 😊👍